### Top 3 Best Arm & Hammer Whitening Toothpastes
Based on recent 2025 reviews from dental experts, consumer sites, and user feedback, I've ranked the top 3 Arm & Hammer whitening toothpastes. These focus on the "White" line and variants emphasizing whitening (e.g., Advance White, PeroxiCare, and Essentials). Rankings prioritize whitening effectiveness, gentleness, overall ratings, and dentist recommendations. All feature baking soda for natural stain removal, but they vary in intensity and added benefits like enamel strengthening.
Rank | Product | Key Whitening Features | Pros | Cons | Average Rating | Source Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Arm & Hammer Advance White Extreme Whitening | Advanced formula with Stain Defense Technology and peroxide for deep stain removal; claims up to 2 shades whiter in weeks. Gentle on enamel. | Effective for surface stains; fresh mint flavor; budget-friendly; low abrasiveness for daily use. | Baking soda aftertaste; may foam excessively. | 4.3/5 (from 484+ reviews) | Top pick for sensitive teeth whitening; outperforms pricier options in cleaning. |
2 | Arm & Hammer PeroxiCare | Baking soda + peroxide blend for gentle whitening and 3x more plaque removal; neutralizes acids for brighter results over time. | Smooth texture; refreshing cool mint; excellent for overall clean + whitening combo. | Milder whitening than extreme formulas; subtle baking soda taste. | 4.8/5 (19/20 in dental eval) | Best overall Arm & Hammer toothpaste with strong whitening; ideal for deep clean without sensitivity. |
3 | Arm & Hammer Essentials Whiten & Strengthen | Natural baking soda + calcium for 2 shades whiter teeth and enamel repair; free of artificial additives. | Pronounced mint flavor; targets stains naturally; strengthens while whitening. | Gritty texture; may increase sensitivity to cold/sweets. | 4.3/5 (17/20 in dental eval) | Specifically the best for dedicated whitening; great for natural-focused users but less comfortable daily. |
These ratings aggregate user reviews (e.g., Amazon, Walmart) and expert tests (e.g., dental advocate scores out of 20 based on effectiveness, comfort, taste, and likability). For best results, pair with regular brushing and consult a dentist for personalized advice. If you meant clinical "reports" (e.g., studies), let me know for deeper dives!