plagiarism ?

Washington Post See realtime coverage

So much overlapped! How can you do that on such stage? got caught red handed! (see Figure below). She diligently read from prompter! Now, they blame the speech writers - poor scapegoats. Don't you see the point? The point is the Trumps got nothing new to offer us! If you copy DNC, why do we need you? All speech writers' thought/ideas - where is yours? Wait, Melanie Trump confessed that she wrote her own speech! below. "blame others, Never deny any wrongdoing!" - That's Trump's playbook (read his camp's denial and accuse, below).(Note, all blue titles below with hypertext linked to the sources). ~~ Republican National Convention: Day One Donald and Melania Trump take the stage. Photo: Joe Raedle/2016 Getty Images There is no reason to go out of the way to be nasty about Melania Trump, an accidental political wife who surely never expected to be playing the part of the immigrant spouse, making the warm and wifely case for her husband’s cold, cruel, anti-immigrant presidential bid on the opening night of the Republican National Convention. But you don’t have to be nasty to her to point out that she was badly ill-served by her husband’s campaign apparatus tonight. Most egregious, as first pointed out by Jarrett Hill on Twitter, is that Melania’s speech appeared to be at least partially lifted from the very successful convention speech given by Michelle Obama in 2008. A large portion of Trump’s oratory — about her parents’ lessons “that you work hard for what you want in life, that your word is your bond and you do what you say and keep your promise, that you treat people with respect” — directly repeated Obama’s story of how she and her husband were both raised with certain values, “that you work hard for what you want in life, that your word is your bond and you do what you say you’re going to do, that you treat people with dignity and respect.” This is a bad — really, really bad — error. It’s the appropriation of a historic speech, made eight years ago by the first African-American First Lady of the United States, by the white woman who wants to succeed her in the White House. Who knows why it happened. Maybe, as Melania claims, she wrote the speech largely on her own; she could have used Michelle’s excellent speech as a model, hewing way too close to it. More likely is that Trump’s staff or speechwriters wrote it, used Michelle’s speech as a model and hewed way too close to it. Either way, it was political malpractice to let this woman go on national television and deliver these stolen words. But even without the plagiarism, Melania’s speech was bad. Dressed in snowy white with poofed things at the end of her sleeves, she looked beautiful, and spoke pleasantly enough. But the words that came out of her mouth were empty, meaningless. If she had really paid attention to Michelle’s speech from 2008, what she should have taken from it was a lesson about the power of narrative specificity: Michelle told detailed, intimate stories of her life as a young person and her life as a wife and mother, details that shed light on her life, her personality, the nature of her relationship with her husband. There was the story of her father, struck in middle age with multiple sclerosis, working every morning to button his shirt and using two canes to cross the room to kiss his wife; there was the memorable scene of Barack driving Malia home from the hospital, “inching along at a snail’s pace, peering anxiously at us in the rearview mirror, feeling the whole weight of her future in his hands …” Melania’s task should have been to humanize her cartoonish thug of a mate, whether by offering a clear picture of herself, of him, or of their family life together. But short of offering the names of her sister, the country of her birth, and her interest in “the incredible arena of fashion,” Melania provided no detail, no specificity. Instead, she delivered 20 minutes of sentences that seemed to emerge at random from a Bland Platitude Generator, a disconcertingly large percentage of which aimed to reassure an audience that her husband actually has cared about the United States prior to 2016: “When it comes to my husband I will say that I am definitely biased and for a good reason. I have been with Donald for 18 years and have been aware of his love for this country since we first met.” “Like me, he loves this country very much.” “The only limit to your achievements is the strength of your dreams and your willingness to work for them.” “My husband has been concerned about our country as long as I have known him.” “With all of my heart, I know he will make a great and lasting difference.” “He will never give up and most importantly he will never let you down.” “His achievements speak for themselves.” Trump’s “kindness is not always noted but it is there for all to see.” “There is no room for small thinking, no room for small results; Donald gets things done.” “My husband’s experience exemplifies growth.” “The race will be hard fought all the way to November. There will be good times and hard times and unexpected turns.” None of these sentences meant anything. They were words without content; clichés as empty and airy as the poofs at the end of her sleeves. Perhaps if she’d had a better speech writer, she wouldn’t have had to steal material from Michelle Obama. But she didn’t have a better speech writer, she didn’t have a better adviser, she didn’t have a better husband, and what Melania Trump is about to have is one of those hard times and unexpected turns she so confidently and blandly predicted. Sad! http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/07/manafort-hillary-is-behind-plagiarism-scandal.html ~~~ "blame others, Never deny any wrongdoing!" - That's Trump's playbook (read his camp's denial and accuse, below).(Note, all blue titles below with hypertext linked to the sources). Republican National Convention: Scrutiny of Melania Trump's speech follows plagiarism allegations Washington Post  - ‎58 minutes ago‎   CLEVELAND - Donald Trump's presidential campaign came under new scrutiny Tuesday after it became apparent that part of Melania Trump's primetime address Monday night at the Republican National Convention bore conspicuous similarities to a ... Why the Plagiarism Problem Matters Zeke J Miller @ZekeJMiller 10:55 AM ET SHARE http://time.com/4412373/why-the-plagiarism-problem-matters/?xid=gonewsedit&google_editors_picks=true (video clip)   Morning Must Reads: July 19 + READ ARTICLE     If you only read one thing: Of all the ways Republicans feared the Donald Trump convention would have hit a speed bump, a plagiarism charge against the candidate’s wife was the last thing on their minds. Sure, they expected a delegate kerfuffle over the party rules as #NeverTrump met its end, but the apparent copying of about 50 words of Michelle Obama’s 2008 convention speech in support of her husband was an unforced error that threatened to overshadow the otherwise golden moment for the Trump campaign. Conventions are multi-day infomercials scripted down to the second, offering campaigns there only opportunity at complete message control, and the sloppiness of Trump’s team points to a larger problem with the organization. While Trump initially told reporters she wrote the speech herself, the campaign backtracked swiftly to say she worked with a team of writers over the course of a month. Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort accused the press of engaging in a political witch-hunt, saying he didn’t see any plagiarism. “They’re not words that are unique words,” he told TIME. Trump’s convention had the look and feel of a traditional political convention, but the message was more designed to tap into the conservative id than the general electorate. With a focus on illegal immigration, Benghazi and police shootings, the opening night featured conservative tropes and speakers who have made their buck on the conservative speaking circuit. To a certain extent, it’s out of necessity, as Trump is still struggling to unify the GOP. Hillary Clinton’s explanation for why her use of a private email server was wrong. The protest scene in Cleveland. And the most political foods in America. Here are your must-reads for now. We’ll be back with more from Cleveland this evening: Must Reads Donald Trump’s Raucous Convention Opens Unconventionally Three television stars. Two Trumps. And one tampon joke. [TIME] Pro-Trump, Anti-Trump Protesters Agree: The Other Side is Brainwashed The scene in Cleveland [TIME] Melania Trump Uses Phrases From Michelle Obama’s 2008 Convention Speech Plagiarism charges mar well-received speech [TIME] Convention Floor Erupts After Never Trump Action Fails The end of Never Trump [TIME] Sign up for and more view example   Sound Off “Frankly if I knew somebody did it, I’d fire them too.” — Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort to TIME Tuesday morning on the Melania Trump speech “Well, it was wrong because—look at what it has—generated.” — Hillary Clinton to Charlie Rose on her private email server Bits and Bites Melania Trump Strikes Rare Note of Compassion at Republican Convention [TIME] How Angry is the Republican Convention Right Now? [TIME] Meet the Rising Star Who Spoke at the Republican Convention [TIME] Rep. Steve King Asks What ‘Subgroup’ Contributed More to Civilization Than Whites [TIME] The Most Political Foods in America [TIME] Do You Eat Like a Republican or a Democrat? [TIME] Donald Trump’s Campaign Still Holding Grudges as Convention Starts [TIME] RNC Chairman Says He’d Consider Firing Melania Trump’s Speechwriter [Bloomberg] Pence vs. Clinton on the Iraq War Vote ‘Mistake’ [Washington Post] Related Donald Trump » Melania Trump » 2016 Republican National Convention » Trump Campaign Struggles to Manage Melania Trump Speech FalloutNBCNews.com Populism Without RacismNew York Times Featured:Did Melania Trump plagiarise Michelle Obama's 2008 Convention speech?Mirror.co.uk Trending on Google+:No one to be fired after Melania Trump speech plagiarism episodeCNN Live Updating:RNC 2016: Watch the Republican convention live stream, Chris Christie, Paul Ryan here starting at 5:30 p.m.NJ.com Wikipedia:2016 Republican National Convention See all 1,922 sources » Related Donald Trump » Melania Trump » 2016 Republican National Convention »     Today.com Melania Trump: 'I Wrote' My RNC Speech 'With As Little Help As Possible' | TODAY - Today.com     Associated Press Similar Speeches: Melania Trump, Michelle Obama - Associated Press       Wall Street Journal Melania Trump/Michelle Obama Speech Similarities - Wall Street Journal

 

 

It is laughable because . . . 　     来源: Derrick_Liu 于 2016-07-19 09:45:11 [档案] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读： 5 次 (462 bytes) 字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题 本文内容已被 [ Derrick_Liu ] 在 2016-07-19 09:45:47 编辑过。如有问题，请报告版主或论坛管理删除. 回答: RNC plagiarism ? 由 TJKCB 于 2016-07-19 09:25:18 Attendees of the the GOP convention were enthralled and were applauding a speech given by . . . Michelle Obama!  BBC News See realtime coverage

Turkey coup: Purge widens to

[TJKCB]

您的位置： 文学城 ? 新闻 ? 焦点新闻 ? 复兴美国？川普娇妻再挨批 从头到脚没有美国货(图)

复兴美国？川普娇妻再挨批 从头到脚没有美国货(图)

文章来源: 苹果日报 于 2016-07-20 10:40:28 - 新闻取自各大新闻媒体，新闻内容并不代表本网立场！


打印本新闻
(被阅读 25247 次)


美国共和党全国代表大会开幕首日，准总统候选人川普的美艳妻子玛莲妮亚（Melania Trump）登台演说，一袭贴身米白色洋装衬托她的好身材，不过眼尖的媒体马上查出，宣称要「让美国再次伟大」的川普夫人，没穿美国设计师的服装鼓励国货，反而穿了要价高达2190美元（约7万元台币）的进口货。

英国《每日邮报》报导称，这件米白色洋装在英国Net-a-Porter网站有售，广告词宣称也可以当做现代新娘的改良式婚纱，在玛莲妮亚穿着它亮相之后，网站上的洋装存货就被抢购一空。

这件洋装出自伦敦设计师、塞尔维亚裔的伊林契奇（Roksanda Ilincic）出手，不少女星、名人穿过它的作品，包括英国凯特王妃、女星葛妮丝派特洛等人，英国首相卡麦隆上星期发表卸任演说，陪在他身边的卡麦隆夫人，也穿着伊林契奇设计的洋装。

川普妻子的发言人说，玛莲妮亚亲自选择这件洋装，因为「她喜欢」，川普幕僚还得意宣称，出身模特儿的玛莲妮亚服装很有品味，她又会说四国语言，「她??会是下一个贾桂琳甘迺迪。」




川普和妻子玛莲妮亚。法新社



玛莲妮亚的洋装令人惊艳。法西摄



路透



凯特王妃也穿过伊林契奇的洋装，这件洋装还穿过不只一次。翻摄《每日邮报》



卡麦隆夫人（右）穿过同一设计师的作品。美联社








?手慢无！贝佳美国专利【骨精华】【心血通】【益脑灵】好礼送不停。6周见效，你还等什么？


?Want to Get the Most Value from Rewards Credit Cards? Check out These Credit Cards with Intro Bonus!


?怎样选购优质美国野生海参？


?打电话回家总是不通？杂音太大还断断续续？海外电信国际长途清晰得就像打本地！


?美国专利[骨胶原]消关节痛/改善骨质疏松，[活心素/灯盏素]强心健脑，[养颜宝] 排毒嫩肤，购两疗程免费寄大陆









相关新闻



美国又高价卖二踢脚给台湾了 要买为什么不买国货(图)




川普娇妻首次站台为丈夫拉票 口音浓重(图/视频)




川普的竞选口号“让美国再强大”就是让美国变白(图)




BBC记者试验在美国只用中国货生活 结果…(组图)




威廉王子挨批"工作懒惰" ？真相是这样的(图)




粗暴川普 全球痛批“丑陋的美国人”(图)




黄玫瑰888 发表评论于 2016-07-20 15:12:11

和肯尼迪夫人比？还是要有点自知之明的啊。

Cathy_Bay 发表评论于 2016-07-20 15:09:16

这也值得反对？美国人敏感地快和天朝有一拼。狭隘

大炮一响 发表评论于 2016-07-20 15:05:58

这和人家穿什么有关系吗？支持川普！

随便说说280 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:57:14

goingplace 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:45:03
这件衣服是挺好看的，爱国也不必狭隘。

=============

同意。 一直觉得床夫人言行举止得体。

床铺归床铺。

随便说说280 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:34:31

graybay 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:05:18
抄袭人自己都承认抄袭了， 川粉们还在继续狡辩。 而且川粉们崇拜的偶像竟然是奥巴马的粉丝，真快要把川粉们气死 。哈哈！ 太滑稽！

============

最新TWITTER 上床铺支持者的理论： 床铺团队故意搞的。 这样床夫人的SPEECH 变成了历史上 MOST TALKED ABOUT CONVENTION SPEECH.

kitday 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:23:59

抄袭算不上，只是引用了同一句名言。再说了，她只是说欣赏奥巴马的夫人，并不是欣赏奥巴马。总统夫人一般不参与政治，只做慈善事业，所以形象比总统好多了。

戴安娜王妃的丈夫形象那么差，戴安娜照样受爱戴。

##^^## 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:18:07

看到RNC上的讲话和这里的评论接轨，我就放心了。原来大趋势是普世价值向中国价值靠拢。

graybay 发表评论于 2016-07-20 14:05:18

抄袭人自己都承认抄袭了， 川粉们还在继续狡辩。 而且川粉们崇拜的偶像竟然是奥巴马的粉丝，真快要把川粉们气死 。哈哈！ 太滑稽！

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:53:47

To lipingDC29:

你沙避被比尔口较弄出来的，你不愚蠢？你被稀老巫婆和同性稿出来的你不丑？你是不是也和老巫婆一样精神有点分裂？我们离十里就闻到你这个男不男女不女的二尾子双性人的狐臭，是想上女厕所就被割过小弟弟变成了女变性人？

haagendaze 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:38:47

又不像michelle一家都花纳税人的钱奢侈旅游，挺好看的一身，没意见

kitday 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:38:10

川普老婆说她一直欣赏米歇尔奥巴马，这不算啥吧。奥巴马是很无能，但是奥巴马老婆又不是坏人。

美国媒体如果能够用这样的态度对待希拉里的机密邮件，希拉里早就进监狱了。

慧眼识猪 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:29:56


事情的确不是孤立的，是要联系， 但也不是神马事都可以连， 还有怎么个连法， 都是有讲究滴， 瞎连一气的只怕就是个精神分裂症啊。

==========================================================
lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:46:37
ztgp3614:愚蠢！能理解这是不同的两件事吗？

愚蠢！！！明白事情不是孤立的，而是相连的吗？明白一些华人的自卑和傲慢是同时存在的吗？明白华人很可能包括你是歧视其它有色人种的吗？

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:28:21

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:15:19 你这个杀避，比尔和女实习生口较的时候把你生出来吧，要么就是稀老巫婆和同性稿的时候把你弄出来的?

To 看得清：

你不仅愚蠢，长得难看，还口臭！

lzh0007 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:19:39

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:31:33
看得清：

你看清什么啦？你什么也没看清！你以为纽约时报是算命大仙啊？
========
是红朝御用风水大师李建军的预测


慧眼识猪 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:16:50


把自己愚蠢的主观臆想强加到别人头上， 然后再狠批一通， 这种人是不是更愚蠢呢？
哎哟喂， 还这么恶狠狠的噢。。。

==============================================================

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:17:15
一些支持川普的华人把美国的暴力事件归结于民主党的多元化政策，我说，愚蠢！，如果不是多元化，你能来美国么？
lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:46:37
ztgp3614:愚蠢！能理解这是不同的两件事吗？

愚蠢！！！明白事情不是孤立的，而是相连的吗？明白一些华人的自卑和傲慢是同时存在的吗？明白华人很可能包括你是歧视其它有色人种的吗？

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:15:19

lipingDC29

你这个杀避，比尔和女实习生口较的时候把你生出来吧，要么就是稀老巫婆和同性稿的时候把你弄出来的?

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 13:05:45

To 看得清：

是“忽悠”，不是“忽有”， 打字时别紧张啊！

就看你给自己起的这个名字，就能看出你是一个自以为是的人，而且长得很丑，我说对了吧？

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:50:28

To lipingDC29:

你真是个若智，纽约时报骗出来就是骗你们这种若智稀饭的，就想留欧的被忽有了一样，你还真信，长点心眼吧，别太缺了。


lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:46:37

ztgp3614:愚蠢！能理解这是不同的两件事吗？

愚蠢！！！明白事情不是孤立的，而是相连的吗？明白一些华人的自卑和傲慢是同时存在的吗？明白华人很可能包括你是歧视其它有色人种的吗？


paulfrank的粉丝 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:44:32

希拉里的水军智商堪忧啊，就算是美国设计师设计的衣服很多也是made in china的，啥叫没有美国货？像奥巴老婆那样把美国商品穿成地摊货感觉的，才是对美国的抱歉好吧。

Chinucks 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:40:07

床铺自己就是义和团员。

Chinucks 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:38:31

敢穿不是Made in USA 的东西，被美国义和团骂骂也正常。

随你怎么玩 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:35:56

床铺老婆抵制美货了，中国爱国贼肯定爽死了

ztgp3614 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:33:52

“一些支持川普的华人把美国的暴力事件归结于民主党的多元化政策，我说，愚蠢！，如果不是多元化，你能来美国么？”
愚蠢！能理解这是不同的两件事吗？

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:31:33

看得清：

你看清什么啦？你什么也没看清！你以为纽约时报是算命大仙啊？

慧眼识猪 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:28:46


真无聊， 拿一个不参政的贤妻良母找茬开刀， 还能不能再Low一点？

看到人家川普太太温良贤淑漂亮优雅，家庭幸福美满，孩子个个成器， 某些人那个羡慕嫉妒恨啊。。。。。。

MovingTarget 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:26:29

美国媒体也耍义和团？不是made in USA不让穿？

北美庆丰 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:23:23

内裤是MadeinChina的。哈哈哈。

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:18:58

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:13:07

纽约时报已经预测了，希拉里有百分之七十六的可能当选下届总统，那些川普的粉丝们，你们要有心理准备！

================================================================

这种左棍的迷信你也信，怎么看怎么象那些留欧的Loser，去年就有个算命白分之百准的超级大仙算床铺胜，但稀拉痢很难斗，你信吗？

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:17:15

一些支持川普的华人把美国的暴力事件归结于民主党的多元化政策，我说，愚蠢！，如果不是多元化，你能来美国么？

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:14:38

嘿嘿，女人无才就是德，床铺老婆是模特，人家床铺过得挺好的，过得罪不好的是比尔大叔，生的女儿都不知道是不是自己的，和老婆长期没性生活，可能还是同志，长得象巫婆，看一眼都想吐，只能出去偷着吃，还被女实习生抖了出去，一个字，惨呀！

lipingDC29 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:13:07

纽约时报已经预测了，希拉里有百分之七十六的可能当选下届总统，那些川普的粉丝们，你们要有心理准备啊！


nanax 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:10:12

365miles 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:38:49
不能苛求人家，因为美国差不多已经不生产服装了，
什么时候穿上美国货的时候就说明美国制造业恢复了。
=================================================
我几个月前在同一家店里连买了两件衣服，都是made in USA，很意外

Jane49Jane 发表评论于 2016-07-20 12:02:39

这次的美国大选太欢乐，川普老婆太给力，严然米雪儿的忠实粉丝一枚，把偶像演讲背的滚瓜烂熟牢记于上还不够，还要在党代会上宣布于众，给力给力，民主党卧底都上川普家了，哈哈哈！

365miles 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:46:13

职业模特心机不多，就不会像稀拉痢一样野心勃勃去干政，对国家是好事。



goingplace 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:45:03

这件衣服是挺好看的，爱国也不必狭隘。


newberry 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:42:16

媒体怎么不怪米歇尔一家度假都是去西班牙？作为个体消费者，自己的钱爱怎么花就怎么花。政府无能腐败媒体还怪消费者不够爱国？如果是中国媒体也就算了，毕竟人家是所谓没有新闻自由或者是国资媒体。美国也这样，还有脸说自己有自由，公正，客观？

jwma 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:41:38


我早就说了川普集团的政治智商令人不齿。这种货如果当选，只能说明美国被红脖子占领了。而这是 显然不可能的。因为绝大多数拉丁人黑人穆斯林和其他少数族裔，绝大多数女人和年轻人，以及知识界文艺界的大多数都不会投川普这个低政治智商满嘴跑火车的种族歧视分子的怕。所以他根本选不上。希拉里也不是什么理想人选，无奈之下，只能两害相权取其轻。


newberry 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:39:35

媒体左派真是恶心。首先，消费者有购物的自由。其次，如果怪罪美国制造业外移，那只能怪是无脑加腐败政客的措施使得制造业外包更有利可图。要怪也要怪政客，居然怪到一个个体消费者了。这个议题被热炒，只能说明两件事情，第一，一部分人智商勘忧，无能力将注意力放在重要议题上，只能无事生非；而另一部分人很高兴能不费吹灰之力把前一部分人的注意力引导在这些琐事上。

磨不开 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:39:17

不要脸啊，连人家穿什么衣服都管上了。

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:39:06

就算是人家崇拜米歇尔的有些比较有价值的话，有错吗？她是夫人，又不是政客，你攻击人家老婆，很无耻。

365miles 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:38:49

不能苛求人家，因为美国差不多已经不生产服装了，
什么时候穿上美国货的时候就说明美国制造业恢复了。



大号蚂蚁 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:37:29

中国批手？爱国就爱国货？

看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:36:03

人家是模特，长得比老巫婆强几百陪，你不承认?不信你盯着稀拉痢疾的照片三分钟，你不吐出来才怪。

大千世界dqsj 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:30:56

没觉得这些衣服好看，领口一律很高，看着不舒服，颜色也不美！

lzh0007 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:30:38

川普的团队被民主党渗透了。但无伤大雅

mingwayhe 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:24:01


川普团队终于承认剽窃：

After spending more than 36 hours directly dismissing charges of plagiarism, the campaign pivoted to acknowledge that passages had been taken from Michelle Obama's 2008 speech to the Democratic National Convention, in what was framed as an innocent mistake.

graybay 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:20:40

复兴美国？川普也就那么一说。 您还真信呀！这哥们活了七十年没有为美国的强大做出过什么贡献。 现在想过把总统瘾才拿复兴美国还忽悠您。

cohcoh 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:20:06

这个女人看上去非常不舒服。

shanshanlaichi 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:19:20

她这件白色套装挺美的
虽然没觉得她人多有气质
但是年轻时候应该也是美艳逼人
否则床铺也不会看上眼

小毛er 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:19:07

恶心。鸡蛋里挑骨头嘛。
川普夫人穿得很优雅大方。
这就够了。

winter1201 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:18:23

没关系，老婆不聪明不是大问题，太聪明了爱管闲事更麻烦。

Bslrim 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:13:03

反正继续斗好了~~~斗到美国分裂才好呢。。。。

whiteblack1 发表评论于 2016-07-20 11:02:45

There is no way for her to be Jackie ! 她的演讲是空的空的，没有内容！

她不是个聪明的女人 !

两岸猿声 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:59:48

川普的老婆减分

JustAsked 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:56:28

鸡蛋里挑骨头。希拉里每天50万美元的竞选经费，把媒体都给收买了！川普怎么做都不对。

脸红脖子粗 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:55:23

虽然支持川普的政策， 但对他选择让自己的老婆出来现眼很反感。 活该他倒霉。

may一day 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:52:07

may一day 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:50:31 OMG!
CNN breaking news! I told you so!
川普的写手辞职，信里说梅烂泥最崇拜的偶像
是米歇尔！
信全文选择在川普乘机去克利夫兰的时间公布，
使他没法及时反击。川普还有一小时才到。
但是记者们都乐疯了，这不是“剽窃门”，这是
“水门”呐！
川普老婆说她最崇拜米歇尔，在电话里读了
米歇尔的演讲给写手。她从始至终就知道是
“学”谁的。
我们一直以为川普是希拉里的卧底，
万没想到他老婆还是奥巴马的潜伏！
没想到呀！太震惊了


看得清 发表评论于 2016-07-20 10:47:04

左棍真的无聊到牙齿和屁股了，人家是夫人，又不选总统,愿意穿啥你管得着吗？稀拉痢疾就穿的都是国货？说被定还有产的呢。


稀拉痢疾那些犯法的,害死人的事咋就不提?

[TJKCB]

What the plagiarism controversy tells us about Trump's campaign


Maeve Reston

By Maeve Reston, CNN


?Updated 11:36 AM ET, Wed July 20, 2016





?




?











?











?











?




























































donald trump wife melania pkg ac360_00012626.jpg
?
?02:56


Melania Trump talks about her role in Trump's campaign ?





melania trump anderson cooper sot ac_00003411.jpg
?
?01:28


Melania Trump: "I don't try to change him" ?





donald trump melania trump 2005 entire larry king live intv_00031417.jpg
?
?16:02


2005: Donald and Melania Trump as newlyweds ?





FLUSHING MEADOWS, UNITED STATES: US real estate tycoon Donald Trump, his wife Melania Knauss and their baby Barron William Trump attend the 2006 US Open men's final between Switzerrland's Roger Federer and Andy Roddick of the US at the USTA National Tennis Center in Flushing Meadows, New York, 10 September 2006. AFP PHOTO/Timothy A. CLARY (Photo credit should read TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/Getty Images)
?
?02:49


Trump's mom, wife born outside U.S. ?





melania trump anderson cooper sot ac_00003411.jpg
?
?01:49


Melania Trump: Donald Trump 'is not racist' ?





donald trump wife melania snl jnd orig pkg_00011415.jpg
?
?01:23


'Trump' in 'SNL' parody: I'm just like you, but better ?





Donald Trump and Melania Trump attend the 2015 New York Spring Spectacular at Radio City Music Hall on March 26, 2015 in New York City.
?
?02:39


Melania Trump: I'm my own person ?





donald trump melania wife campaign lemon intv_00003926.jpg
?
?00:46


Donald Trump talks about wife Melania ?





donald trump wife melania dnt todd tsr_00004312.jpg
?
?02:20


Former supermodel could be the First Lady ?





Donald Trump and Melania Trump attend the 2015 New York Spring Spectacular at Radio City Music Hall on March 26, 2015 in New York City.
?
?01:45


Who is Melania Trump? ?








Now Playing



Manafort: Media should 'move on' from Melania's speech ?





Melania Trump, wife of Presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, delivers a speech on the first day of the Republican National Convention on July 18, 2016 at the Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland, Ohio. An estimated 50,000 people are expected in Cleveland, including hundreds of protesters and members of the media. The four-day Republican National Convention kicks off on July 18.

?02:18


How journalist spotted the plagiarized speech ?





rnc melania trump plagiarism paul manafort cuomo intv newday_00001720.jpg

?01:30


Manafort: Plagiarism accusations are crazy ?







?01:42


Side-by-side of Melania Trump, Michelle Obama speeches ?





Melania Trump, wife of Presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, delivers a speech on the first day of the Republican National Convention on July 18, 2016 at the Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland, Ohio.

?02:19


Melania Trump: I wrote the speech with a little help ?






?
?02:29


Melania Trump's speech bears resemblance to Obama's ?





melania trump michelle obama plagiarized manu raju sot_00003422.jpg
?
?01:53


Trump campaign comments on Melania Trump's speech ?






?
?01:47


Melania Trump: Donald has history of inclusion ?






?
?04:08


Melania Trump: Being a U.S. citizen is a privilege ?





Melania Trump
?
?02:36


A look at Melania Trump on the campaign trail ?





donald trump wife melania pkg ac360_00012626.jpg
?
?02:56


Melania Trump talks about her role in Trump's campaign ?





melania trump anderson cooper sot ac_00003411.jpg
?
?01:28


Melania Trump: "I don't try to change him" ?





donald trump melania trump 2005 entire larry king live intv_00031417.jpg
?
?16:02


2005: Donald and Melania Trump as newlyweds ?





FLUSHING MEADOWS, UNITED STATES: US real estate tycoon Donald Trump, his wife Melania Knauss and their baby Barron William Trump attend the 2006 US Open men's final between Switzerrland's Roger Federer and Andy Roddick of the US at the USTA National Tennis Center in Flushing Meadows, New York, 10 September 2006. AFP PHOTO/Timothy A. CLARY (Photo credit should read TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/Getty Images)
?
?02:49


Trump's mom, wife born outside U.S. ?





melania trump anderson cooper sot ac_00003411.jpg
?
?01:49


Melania Trump: Donald Trump 'is not racist' ?





donald trump wife melania snl jnd orig pkg_00011415.jpg
?
?01:23


'Trump' in 'SNL' parody: I'm just like you, but better ?





Donald Trump and Melania Trump attend the 2015 New York Spring Spectacular at Radio City Music Hall on March 26, 2015 in New York City.
?
?02:39


Melania Trump: I'm my own person ?





donald trump melania wife campaign lemon intv_00003926.jpg
?
?00:46


Donald Trump talks about wife Melania ?





donald trump wife melania dnt todd tsr_00004312.jpg
?
?02:20


Former supermodel could be the First Lady ?





Donald Trump and Melania Trump attend the 2015 New York Spring Spectacular at Radio City Music Hall on March 26, 2015 in New York City.
?
?01:45


Who is Melania Trump? ?







?02:20


Manafort: Media should 'move on' from Melania's speech ?





Melania Trump, wife of Presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, delivers a speech on the first day of the Republican National Convention on July 18, 2016 at the Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland, Ohio. An estimated 50,000 people are expected in Cleveland, including hundreds of protesters and members of the media. The four-day Republican National Convention kicks off on July 18.

?02:18


How journalist spotted the plagiarized speech ?





rnc melania trump plagiarism paul manafort cuomo intv newday_00001720.jpg

?01:30


Manafort: Plagiarism accusations are crazy ?







?01:42


Side-by-side of Melania Trump, Michelle Obama speeches ?





Melania Trump, wife of Presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump, delivers a speech on the first day of the Republican National Convention on July 18, 2016 at the Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland, Ohio.

?02:19


Melania Trump: I wrote the speech with a little help ?






?
?02:29


Melania Trump's speech bears resemblance to Obama's ?





melania trump michelle obama plagiarized manu raju sot_00003422.jpg
?
?01:53


Trump campaign comments on Melania Trump's speech ?






?
?01:47


Melania Trump: Donald has history of inclusion ?






?
?04:08


Melania Trump: Being a U.S. citizen is a privilege ?





Melania Trump
?
?02:36


A look at Melania Trump on the campaign trail ?
.

?

?








Story highlights
Plagiarism controversy is yet another unsettling episode for the Trump campaign
No immediate sign of a campaign shakeup




Cleveland (CNN) — Donald Trump claimed the Republican nomination Tuesday after flattening the establishment with his unorthodox campaign -- but his convention is also exposing the downside of his freewheeling approach.

The Trump campaign descended into a familiar messiness after Melania Trump delivered a convention speech Monday echoing lines from Michelle Obama's 2008 convention address.



On the tumultuous day that followed, Donald Trump was furious. Melania Trump was humiliated. And the campaign, which had appeared to be on the path to becoming a more organized, disciplined operation, was back on its heels, dealing with swirling accusations and internal finger-pointing that yielded no real answers about what happened.

No one to be fired after Melania Trump speech plagiarism

There was no immediate sign of a campaign shakeup Wednesday and it remains unclear whether the incident will have a lasting effect.







Trump's campaign chairman Paul Manafort continued to refuse to acknowledge Wednesday morning that parts of Melania Trump's convention speech were lifted lines, saying the controversy is "not meaningful at all."

"The speech was very effective and communicated those feelings," Manafort told CNN's Chris Cuomo on "New Day." "The controversy you're talking about is not meaningful at all. She's not a candidate for office. She was expressing her personal feelings about her country and her husband and why he's best for the United States."

It is yet another unsettling episode for the Trump campaign at a time when many top donors are closely watching Trump and his operation to determine whether it is worth their investment this fall.





Side-by-side of Melania Trump, Michelle Obama speeches

?

?






Side-by-side of Melania Trump, Michelle Obama speeches

















Watch this video




Related Video: Side-by-side of Melania Trump, Michelle Obama speeches 01:42

Melania Trump's convention speech was billed as one of the highlights of this week, one that could help humanize him and appeal to female voters concerned about his temperament. In the moment, it seemed like an elegant triumph for the Republican nominee, who proudly escorted his wife off stage after a kiss. But soon side-by-side comparisons of Melania Trump's remarks and Michelle Obama's 2008 speech were playing non-stop on the networks.

The trouble seemed to subside for the time being Tuesday when Trump won the roll call vote that officially made him the Republican nominee and a series of speakers -- most notably New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie -- forcefully argued against Hillary Clinton's candidacy.

It is clear that Trump's children, who are new to politics, are a driving force guiding their father, but sometimes appear out of their depth when it comes to the necessary infrastructure of a general election campaign — particularly when the candidate has insisted that it stay lean and mean.

Donald Trump claims GOP mantle

Manafort's team has brought depth and experience to the team — and he pulled off an impressive feat last week by squelching a rebellion in the rules committee with a team of 100 lawyers. They have also worked effectively to sway Republican delegates who had once been hesitant to support Trump.


Skeletal communications staff

But the campaign's skeletal communications staff is still struggling to drive a daily message or even control the candidate's insatiable appetite for media attention. Trump, for example, inexplicably called in to give an interview with Fox Monday night -- missing a poignant speech by two survivors of the Benghazi attack.

On Tuesday, Trump aides and allies were at a loss to explain who wrote Melania's speech and how the plagiarism had occurred. The campaign's spokesman produced an incoherent statement at nearly 2 a.m. Tuesday that referred to "Melania's team of writers" without identifying any of them. That directly conflicted with Melania Trump's comment earlier to Matt Lauer on "Today" that she wrote her speech with "as little help as possible."



CNN Politics app
When Manafort appeared on CNN Tuesday morning, he called the accusation of plagiarism "just really absurd." He insisted Melania had used "common words" and not "cribbed" from Michelle Obama's speech. Around the same time, RNC Chairman Reince Priebus told reporters at a Bloomberg Politics breakfast he'd "probably" fire whoever was responsible for the plagiarized quotes.

In the next dramatic twist, Trump's recently fired campaign manager Corey Lewandowski said Manafort, his former rival on the Trump campaign, should take responsibility for the controversy, noting that Manafort was brought on to have oversight of every aspect of the convention.

Bob Dole reflects on Trump

"The buck stops at the top," Lewandowski, a CNN contributor, said.

"I think it's shameful that Melania Trump, who is such a great person, who represents her husband and would represent this country amazingly as first lady, is under this controversy because the staff didn't do her well," Lewandowski said.

Of Manafort, he said, "Whoever signed off, with the final sign off, and allowed this to go forward, should be held accountable," he said. "I think if it was Paul Manafort, he'd do the right thing and resign."



?


Manafort: Media should 'move on' from Melania's speech

?

?






Manafort: Media should 'move on' from Melania's speech

















Watch this video




Related Video: Manafort: Media should 'move on' from Melania's speech 02:20

The Trump campaign then said no one would be fired or disciplined over the incident.

Multiple sources with knowledge of the speech writing process within the campaign said Trump's son-in-law and trusted confidante, Jared Kushner, got the ball rolling in June when he enlisted two pre-eminent speechwriters, Matthew Scully, a speechwriter for George W. Bush, and his partner John McConnell, to draft Melania's speech.

Melania Trump's unexpected moment

They delivered a prospective speech to the campaign that incorporated humor, some light teasing of the real estate magnate and a focus on her upbringing in Slovenia and efforts to become an American citizen, according to several sources who read the original draft.

The draft was well received by the Trump campaign mid-June. But somewhat mysteriously, Scully and McConnell were not consulted again.

The speech Melania Trump delivered on Monday night was an entirely different speech than what they had drafted, with the exception of a half-dozen lines. The controversial lines echoing Michelle Obama's speech were not in Scully and McConnell's original draft.


No clarity about who was responsible

Trump advisers said Tuesday that Melania had been guided by a number of different people throughout the process, but offered no clarity about who was responsible for the paragraph and phrases in question.

Donald Trump Jr. defended both Melania and Manafort during an interview with CBS This Morning Co-host Norah O'Donnell -- batting away Lewandowski's comments.

"There's a reason Paul is in the position that he is today and Corey is not, and it is not because Paul is amateur hour," Donald Trump Jr. said. "I think it is nonsense. I heard that other people ask 'Oh, is the family on the outs with Paul?' Total nonsense."





Lewandowski: Staffer behind speech should resign

?

?






corey lewandowski melania trump plagiarism speech staffer resign atthishour_00005822

















Watch this video




Related Video: Lewandowski: Staffer behind speech should resign 01:21

Perhaps because of the possible backlash effect of speaking negatively about a Republican candidate's wife who has been reluctant to seek the spotlight, Democrats largely avoided commenting on the controversy on Tuesday.

While the Trump campaign released talking points on how to respond, most surrogates did not appear to take the campaign's lead.

Perhaps the most unusual response on the controversy came from former 2016 candidate Ben Carson, when he was asked about the plagiarism charge after addressing the Florida delegation breakfast.

Nightcap: The latest news and political buzz from CNN Politics | Sign up

"I think what we should be thinking about is if Melania's speech is similar to Michelle Obama's speech, that should make us all very happy because we should be saying whether we're Democrats or Republicans, we share the same values," Carson said. "That's what we should be talking about. Not trying to make it controversy."

CNN's Ashley Killough and Eugene Scott contributed to this story

[TJKCB]

看这儿的评论，好像有人还真没把在美国搞文字剽窃当一回事。醒醒吧，准备推娃的爸妈们，这儿不是在天朝：-）
　
来源: tud 于 2016-07-19 21:21:47 [档案] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：55 次 (593 bytes)
字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题
回答: 有这样的老婆真要命。 由 千里一盏灯 于 2016-07-19 20:19:01
或者除非你混成像川普这样的超级大款，法律在这种层次上是为你说话的。

对申请大学来说，如果招生人员发现申请者有文字剽窃现象，申请者就铁定出局了。而且有没有文字剽窃这个问题，解释权是在别人手上。

我孩子在申请大学时，有些申请材料，尤其是诗词类的，写完后都在网上先查一下，就是防止有类同的。这些方法都是学校教的，有专门的网站可以帮助做这事。

在美国，这是件非常严肃的事。

[TJKCB]

所有跟帖：
? 那些话大家都有说，况且要真说剽窃，08老婆也是剽窃了一本书上的话。不能把一些大家都经常用来教育小孩的话 -CarriePanda- ♀ (196 bytes) (54 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:26:34
? 如果同某本书上的话一样，估计没人有意见，关键是相同场合下的类似话，太显眼了 -没树的小林- ♂ (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:29:21
? 说剽窃有点过分，但是叫“拾人牙慧”，“人云亦云”应该是比较恰当的。 -千里一盏灯- ♂ (68 bytes) (17 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:30:58
? 我不觉得，那些励志话好像到处都是，怎么Trump 老婆就不能说了？就是没新意而已。 -CarriePanda- ♀ (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:32:41
? 那几个句子，唉！你看一下就知道为什么大家说了一天一夜 -没树的小林- ♂ (0 bytes) (4 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:36:12
? 那几句确实太明显照搬了，辫子太粗，不怪人抓小辫。 -高筋粉- ♀ (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:45:20
? 老婆傻点好：） --百科-- ♀ (0 bytes) (7 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:29:15
? 我就觉得床破老婆比O8老婆看着顺眼 -没树的小林- ♂ (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:30:35
? 顺眼太太多了！08还可以，他太太实在太难看了！ -高筋粉- ♀ (0 bytes) (3 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:31:47
? 所以天天吃醋呀，哈哈。 -CarriePanda- ♀ (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:33:10
? 现在又再扒她学历造假了。 -千里一盏灯- ♂ (176 bytes) (62 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:38:13
? 模特反正不需要学位。斯洛文尼亚的大学估计还是野鸡大学的学位跟没有也差不多。改天她拿个自家大学学位就行了 -greenoasis- ♀ (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:44:37
? 美国的主流媒体堕落到这么无聊的地步。动摇国体、国计民生大事捂住眼睛假装看不见，黑起床铺来不遗余力 -尔思- ♀ (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 21:10:56
? 这种事情太有娱乐性了。特朗普的竞选就像他的电视节目，充满unpredictable 娱乐性，美国人爱看，所以很支持他当总统。哈哈 -飞*星- ♂ (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 21:24:22
? 真是这样? 哈哈，哈哈。。看来川大人应该把这样坑夫的老婆休了。 -飞*星- ♂ (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:39:37
? 我怀疑他早就想换了，现在这个太老了，都４６岁了ＬＯＬ -没树的小林- ♂ (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:40:18
? 真假？这场合的讲稿不可能没人把关。川普要是当了总统也还这么2倒是真麻烦了。他老婆漂漂亮亮说几句话谁也不在意都说了什么。好看就行 -greenoasis- ♀ (0 bytes) (7 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:42:30
? 就是怕他改不了2 的 风格。你够幽默，笑死我了。 -笑薇.- ♀ (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:53:02
? 这个老婆够麻烦，抄袭他人之作，编造学历，还口口声声说，在竞选上，她给trump advise。那次之后，她就 -笑薇.- ♀ (161 bytes) (105 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 20:58:21
? 看这儿的评论，好像有人还真没把在美国搞文字剽窃当一回事。醒醒吧，准备推娃的爸妈们，这儿不是在天朝：-） -tud- ♂ (593 bytes) (54 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 21:21:47

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 子女教育 ? 看这儿的评论，好像有人还真没把在美国搞文字剽窃当一回事。醒醒吧，准备推娃的爸妈们，这儿不是在天朝：-） 全部论坛列表


看这儿的评论，好像有人还真没把在美国搞文字剽窃当一回事。醒醒吧，准备推娃的爸妈们，这儿不是在天朝：-）
　
来源: tud 于 2016-07-19 21:21:47 [档案] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：55 次 (593 bytes)
字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题
回答: 有这样的老婆真要命。 由 千里一盏灯 于 2016-07-19 20:19:01
或者除非你混成像川普这样的超级大款，法律在这种层次上是为你说话的。

对申请大学来说，如果招生人员发现申请者有文字剽窃现象，申请者就铁定出局了。而且有没有文字剽窃这个问题，解释权是在别人手上。

我孩子在申请大学时，有些申请材料，尤其是诗词类的，写完后都在网上先查一下，就是防止有类同的。这些方法都是学校教的，有专门的网站可以帮助做这事。

在美国，这是件非常严肃的事。

[TJKCB]

?












Education



Teachers: Melania Trump would have gotten an F — or even expelled — if she’d turned in her speech for a class






































By Emma Brown, Nick Anderson and T. Rees Shapiro

July 19 at 1:11 PM ?





Melania Trump's 2016 speech vs. Michelle Obama's 2008 speech
? ?

?Play Video1:56


Melania Trump’s speech at the GOP convention in Cleveland is drawing comparisons to Michelle Obama’s speech at the 2008 Democratic National Convention in Denver. Here’s a side-by-side look at both. (Jenny Starrs/The Washington Post)



It’s not clear whether there will be any long-term political fallout from Melania Trump’s speech Monday night, in which she introduced herself to the nation with passages that closely mirrored a speech Michelle Obama first delivered eight years ago.

But high school teachers and college professors say it is almost certain that if Melania Trump were a student turning in a paper — rather than a prospective First Lady giving a convention speech — the consequences would be serious, ranging from an F on the assignment to expulsion from school.

Josh Davis, who teaches high school English and journalism in Beachwood, Ohio, said Trump’s speech is a classic example of the kind of plagiarism he sees among high school students.

























Local Headlines newsletter

Daily headlines about the Washington region.






Sign up






“Sure, some words were changed, but the shell is the same,” Davis said. “It’s a pretty clear example of what I might see, where a student took another kid’s paper and changed half a dozen words and said ‘Oh, I paraphrased it, so it’s mine.’ And I say, ‘No, you plagiarized it.'”

Davis said a student who borrowed as much language as Trump would likely get a zero on the assignment — along with a lesson on why plagiarism is wrong. Sometimes, he said, such borrowing is a sign of a student who is struggling.

[Melania Trump’s speech appears to have cribbed from Michelle Obama’s in 2008]

“Frequently, students that resort to that — not to excuse it — but frequently, in high school, it’s issues with ability,” he said. “Students who are in over their head are more likely to resort to something like that.”

Davis plans to vote for Hillary Clinton. But he said plagiarism is not a problem confined to the GOP, citing accusations of plagiarism that helped derail the 1988 presidential campaign of now-Vice President Joe Biden. “Even though I’m a Democrat, I haven’t had much respect for him because of that.”

Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort has denied that Melania Trump’s speech included any plagiarism.

“There’s no cribbing of Michelle Obama’s speech. These were common words and values that she cares about, her family, things like that,” Manafort said on CNN’s “New Day” Tuesday morning. “She was speaking in front of 35 million people last night, she knew that, to think that she would be cribbing Michelle Obama’s words is crazy.”


[Scrutiny of Melania Trump’s speech follows plagiarism allegations]







But a specialist in ethics at Dartmouth College said Trump’s speech struck her as a clear-cut case of plagiarism.

If a college student had turned in a paper with the same amount of verbal overlap that Melania Trump’s speech contained, “that student would have been brought up on plagiarism charges, no doubt,” said Aine Donovan, director of the Ethics Institute at Dartmouth.

Donovan said the sanctions students would face for such an offense vary from school to school. “They would be at minimum chastised, at worst separated from the college or the university,” she said.

Colleges sometimes make distinctions in judging plagiarism, finding certain cases to be slight verbal overlaps and others total cut-and-paste jobs.

“This would definitely be at minimum a yellow flag,” Donovan said of Trump’s speech, but she noted that college students are held to a different standard than politicians. “We’re trying to train students in principles of integrity and academic honesty.”

Donovan said she has taught at colleges with strong honor codes, including Dartmouth and the U.S. Naval Academy. “So many undergrads don’t understand the concept of honor. We take it very seriously,” she said. “Somebody could say, ‘Who cares about words? Who cares about plagiarism?’ Well, there’s a slippery slope involved.”

Perhaps no one is more familiar with that slippery slope than Jayson Blair, who was seen as a rising star in journalism before he resigned from the New York Times in 2003, admitting at the time to plagiarizing and fabricating facts and scenes in dozens of his articles, including in coverage of the Washington-area sniper case. The Times called Blair’s misdeeds “journalistic fraud” that tarnished the newspaper’s reputation.

Blair said he now speaks often to high school and college students about the lasting impact that his decision to plagiarize has had on his personal life and professional career.

“When you commit plagiarism on a national stage it really has the opportunity to significantly set back your life and your career,” Blair said. Copying someone else’s language makes it appear that “you’re willing to take from others without giving credit. It makes you seem as if you don’t have original ideas,” Blair said.


Several years ago, Blair said, a college journalism professor called him for advice about a student who had shown great promise but who was caught plagiarizing. Blair said that he spoke to the student and talked with him about the consequences of copying others’ work.

“My consequence was very public, and I’ve had the opportunity to rebuild, but I can never go into the profession I love the most,” Blair said. “I’m banned and barred for life from that field.”

Blair said that, in the end, the professor opted to fail the student rather than force his expulsion. Blair has since kept tabs on the student, and with Blair’s help, the student apparently learned his lesson: He still works in journalism today, Blair said.

[TJKCB]

Jim Morrison

6:17 PM PDT [Edited]









Why wasn't Martin Luther King's Doctorate rightfully revoked when scholars later discovered and declared that he plagiarized his dissertation thesis while at Boston University? That sure didn't demonstrate very good content of character.














LikeReplyShare





























Brad Plows

6:08 PM PDT









Obama did the same thing in 2008. As well as joe Biden.
















LikeReplyShare





























Stayin'Alive

5:28 PM PDT









Certainly it wasn't Melania Trump who plagiarized Michelle Obama, just as certainly as the responsibility lies with the Joseph Goebbels-like Paul Manatort. He is either directly responsible, or more likely is simply the poor (and bullying) campaign manger he appears to be.

One thing is certain: the phrase "your word is your bond" has its roots directly in African-American history. Since I rather doubt the south of Slovenia gave rise to such a phrase, then unless Melanie shares that culture with Michelle Obama, or is a student of the history and culture of Blacks in America, her words were absolutely plagiarized... something we already know.














LikeReplyShare





























Landy00

5:12 PM PDT









Find this hard to believe. Most high school grads have trouble reading, spelling and writing. It is already been proven that college kids buy their papers online and cheating is at an all time high.














LikeReplyShare





























Daniel Leonard

4:45 PM PDT









It is nice to see that the teachers are out in force to grade Ms Trump's speech. Too bad the same teachers never speak out regarding the deplorable grammar employed by journalists on a daily basis. Beginning a sentence with a conjunction (such as,"But he said plagiarism...", from the foregoing article) and the continual use of "different than" in writing everywhere one turns. One phrase (mis)used constantly by people who SHOULD know better is the reference to "healthy" foods. This, of course, indicates that the food in question is suffering from no illness. The question of whether or not that food is healthful is left unanswered. If only the teachers themselves had the ability to properly use our language correctly, they probably would have long ago began grading the press - and the grades would be abysmally low.














LikeReplyShare





























Chris Henne

4:27 PM PDT









Teachers are morons... 1 she didnt write it she just delivered it... 2 you let far worse get through in your classrooms.














LikeReplyShare


2 ·



























Bern Grosse

3:30 PM PDT









Apparently none of you have ever read Michele Obama's Master's Thesis. If you are interested in an adventure in imbecility and hideous underachievement read it. As the late Christopher Hitchens said, " It was written in a language he had never seen before." Sheer illiteracy and ignorance on putrid display. Your writers need to take some remedial courses in journalistic honesty.














LikeReplyShare


1 ·



























Mfuta

3:29 PM PDT









What do you expect from a college drop out?














LikeReplyShare


















Chris Henne

4:34 PM PDT









except.... she didnt write it, she just delivered it














LikeReply


















Stayin'Alive

5:32 PM PDT









"except.... she didnt write it, she just delivered it"

Even worse! If she doesn't know what she's saying or where it came from, she's as vacuous as she appears to be, and would only make a good First Fashion Model.














Like



















































Mary Stein

3:14 PM PDT









How many times have our parents and grand=parents said those same words to us as children? The words, nor the phraseology is not new nor do they belong solely to Michelle Obama. Those words belong to every parent and grand -parent who wanted nothing more than to raise good, decent, law abiding children and secure a more peaceful future for all of us.














LikeReplyShare


4 ·
















cris12356

3:41 PM PDT









That doesn't matter, if she wants to be our First Lady, shouldn't she have put in just a little effort and not stolen a speech?














LikeReply


1 ·
















Barry Davis

4:07 PM PDT









While I don't condone delivering a "stolen" speech, when it becomes the duty of the First Lady to create domestic and foreign policy, and to deliver important speeches to cabinet meetings, to Congress, and not just for the press, then I will agree.














Like


1 ·






































Eric Kilian

5:43 PM PDT









Apparently you don't understand how plagiarism works, Mary. Those weren't just similar ideas. Those were strings of words combined in the exact same order. That doesn't happen by chance. Whoever "wrote" that speech copied part of it directly from Mrs. Obama's 2008 speech.

And if you want to secure a "more peaceful future", I've no idea why you'd defend the Trumps. Donald literally said we should kill innocent family members of terrorists. Real "peaceful".














LikeReply








































conare

2:58 PM PDT









Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort has denied that Melania Trump’s speech included any plagiarism.

“There’s no cribbing of Michelle Obama’s speech. These were common words and values that she cares about, her family, things like that,”

how to lose all credibility in two sentences flat ^^^^^















LikeReplyShare


1 ·



























RFinley

2:34 PM PDT









Poor Melania! I find her engaging, classy and intelligent. But there is no hiding this inexcusable snafu..Due diligence fail at its worst! Hearing the Trump Camp excuse it away is like finding your spouse in bed with your best friend and saying "Honey its not what you think"!!
If I were Melania, it would be a left hook to her speech writer and a swift kick in the balls for her husband!














LikeReplyShare


3 ·
















cris12356

3:43 PM PDT









She said and I quote "I wrote it with a LITTLE help",when Matt Lauer interviewed her. Intelligent? She speaks broken English and dropped out of college.














LikeReply


















Chris Henne

4:30 PM PDT









Speaking English i s not a sign or absence of intelligence, nor is completing or dropping out of college. Do you speak Swahili? No? Then you must be an imbecile! Her English is broken because she is a foreigner, NOT bc she is not intelligent. Im not saying she is intelligent, Im just saying youre a moron for that argument.














Like



















































dbothroydearthlinknet

2:33 PM PDT









I think the F would go to the writers of this for petty cattyness














LikeReplyShare


1 ·
















washingtonpostid4comment

2:40 PM PDT









If this is what they have to focus on, you know they don't have much else.....














LikeReply








































washingtonpostid4comment

2:09 PM PDT









"It’s not clear whether there will be any long-term political fallout from Melania Trump’s speech Monday night...." but we are trying our best to make that happen! We are taking a very unimportant issue and trying to make it huge and ongoing.














LikeReplyShare


1 ·
















Eyerty

2:19 PM PDT









Benghazi! (always wanted to say that, ha ha)














LikeReply


2 ·






































Garrett Jackson

1:04 PM PDT









This entire episode will be forgiven by half our nation and criticized by the other half. We no longer argue ideas but rather takes sides blindly behind our party, the left versus the right and just as sad those who follow blindly their church. I'm disappointed in our country and what it has become. I certainly won't waste my time voting or praying for its healing. I no longer have faith in either.














LikeReplyShare


2 ·



























BillFrancis - Summerfield Florida

1:01 PM PDT









some Trump speech writers are now fired, as they should be.

[TJKCB]

"Trump's campaign denied accusations that a portion of Melania Trump's first night speech was plagiarized, she used "common words." Others affiliated with the campaign seemed to concede there were some similarities. " What example do you set for students in school?

[TJKCB]

? Trump's campaign denied accusations that a portion of Melania Trump's first night speech was plagiarized, she used "common words." Others affiliated with the campaign seemed to concede there were some similarities.

[TJKCB]

NYMag.com

Daily Intelligencer

Vulture

The Cut

Science of Us

Select All

Grub Street

Bedford & Bowery


FOLLOW:

Facebook

Twitter

Instagram






LOG IN|

REGISTER



New York magazine intel



Subscribe ?

Give a Gift ?

Digital Edition ?













Home

News & Politics


Daily Intelligencer

Jonathan Chait

Marin Cogan

Ed Kilgore

Annie Lowrey

Frank Rich

Chris Smith

Rebecca Traister

Entertainment


Vulture

Art

Books

Classical & Dance

Movies

Music

Theater

TV

Agenda: To Do This Week

Fashion


The Cut

Beauty

Fashion News & Trends

Fashion Shows

Street Style

Celebrity Style

Designers

Models

Goods & Product Picks

Love & War

Restaurants


Restaurants Search & Menus

Grub Street

Best of NY Food

Cheap Eats

Where to Eat 2016

Recipes

Bars


Bar Search

Best of NY Nightlife

Stores


Store Search

Best of NY Shopping

Home Design

Goods & Product Picks

The Magazine


Subscribe Now

Give Gift Subscription

Download the App

Buy Back Issues

View Current Issue

Online Issue Archive

Customer Service

Media Kit







Travel Design Weddings Real Estate Doctors NYC Tourist Guide Best of New York Issue Deals















Daily Intelligencer
/early and often
July 19, 2016
1:56 a.m.

The Trump Campaign Failed Melania — and Not Just Because of the Plagiarism
By Rebecca Traister



5k
Shares

Share
5k

Tweet
0

Share
18

Share
6

Email

154

Print




Republican National Convention: Day One



Donald and Melania Trump take the stage. Photo: Joe Raedle/2016 Getty Images

There is no reason to go out of the way to be nasty about Melania Trump, an accidental political wife who surely never expected to be playing the part of the immigrant spouse, making the warm and wifely case for her husband’s cold, cruel, anti-immigrant presidential bid on the opening night of the Republican National Convention. But you don’t have to be nasty to her to point out that she was badly ill-served by her husband’s campaign apparatus tonight.

Most egregious, as first pointed out by Jarrett Hill on Twitter, is that Melania’s speech appeared to be at least partially lifted from the very successful convention speech given by Michelle Obama in 2008. A large portion of Trump’s oratory — about her parents’ lessons “that you work hard for what you want in life, that your word is your bond and you do what you say and keep your promise, that you treat people with respect” — directly repeated Obama’s story of how she and her husband were both raised with certain values, “that you work hard for what you want in life, that your word is your bond and you do what you say you’re going to do, that you treat people with dignity and respect.”

This is a bad — really, really bad — error. It’s the appropriation of a historic speech, made eight years ago by the first African-American First Lady of the United States, by the white woman who wants to succeed her in the White House. Who knows why it happened. Maybe, as Melania claims, she wrote the speech largely on her own; she could have used Michelle’s excellent speech as a model, hewing way too close to it. More likely is that Trump’s staff or speechwriters wrote it, used Michelle’s speech as a model and hewed way too close to it. Either way, it was political malpractice to let this woman go on national television and deliver these stolen words.


But even without the plagiarism, Melania’s speech was bad. Dressed in snowy white with poofed things at the end of her sleeves, she looked beautiful, and spoke pleasantly enough. But the words that came out of her mouth were empty, meaningless. If she had really paid attention to Michelle’s speech from 2008, what she should have taken from it was a lesson about the power of narrative specificity: Michelle told detailed, intimate stories of her life as a young person and her life as a wife and mother, details that shed light on her life, her personality, the nature of her relationship with her husband. There was the story of her father, struck in middle age with multiple sclerosis, working every morning to button his shirt and using two canes to cross the room to kiss his wife; there was the memorable scene of Barack driving Malia home from the hospital, “inching along at a snail’s pace, peering anxiously at us in the rearview mirror, feeling the whole weight of her future in his hands …”



Melania’s task should have been to humanize her cartoonish thug of a mate, whether by offering a clear picture of herself, of him, or of their family life together. But short of offering the names of her sister, the country of her birth, and her interest in “the incredible arena of fashion,” Melania provided no detail, no specificity. Instead, she delivered 20 minutes of sentences that seemed to emerge at random from a Bland Platitude Generator, a disconcertingly large percentage of which aimed to reassure an audience that her husband actually has cared about the United States prior to 2016:

“When it comes to my husband I will say that I am definitely biased and for a good reason. I have been with Donald for 18 years and have been aware of his love for this country since we first met.”

“Like me, he loves this country very much.”

“The only limit to your achievements is the strength of your dreams and your willingness to work for them.”

“My husband has been concerned about our country as long as I have known him.”

“With all of my heart, I know he will make a great and lasting difference.”

“He will never give up and most importantly he will never let you down.”

“His achievements speak for themselves.”

Trump’s “kindness is not always noted but it is there for all to see.”

“There is no room for small thinking, no room for small results; Donald gets things done.”

“My husband’s experience exemplifies growth.”

“The race will be hard fought all the way to November. There will be good times and hard times and unexpected turns.”

None of these sentences meant anything. They were words without content; clichés as empty and airy as the poofs at the end of her sleeves. Perhaps if she’d had a better speech writer, she wouldn’t have had to steal material from Michelle Obama. But she didn’t have a better speech writer, she didn’t have a better adviser, she didn’t have a better husband, and what Melania Trump is about to have is one of those hard times and unexpected turns she so confidently and blandly predicted. Sad!
http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/07/manafort-hillary-is-behind-plagiarism-scandal.html

[TJKCB]

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 时事述评 ? 所有在市场上可以见到的专业竞选助选人员都是professional,比如那些搞民意测验，搞竞选筹资的，，，之类的，都是生意人，今

全部论坛列表





所有在市场上可以见到的专业竞选助选人员都是professional,比如那些搞民意测验，搞竞选筹资的，，，之类的，都是生意人，今

　



来源: FastTurtle 于 2016-07-19 11:07:50 [档案] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：3 次 (1155 bytes)

字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题


回答: 别提侵权，先看看Michelle Obama 有版权吗？-看看同样标准下Michelle Obama是不是也是Plagiariz 由 smalleagle 于 2016-07-19 09:10:17




她的讲话很长，就有两段＂好好学习，天天向上＂的段子几乎每个政客都要讲的玩意，算了吧 ,speech writer 是个生意，，所有在市场上可以见到的专业竞选助选人员都是professional,比如那些搞民意测验，搞竞选筹资的，，，之类的，都是生意人，今天给 R党搭台，明天给D党洗地，这个都是谋生的手段，好的总统演讲拟稿人也是如此，为什么希拉里指控OB抄某某的演讲，因为这个市场里的人参考的演讲标准就是 大同小异，看竞选看的是大局，大的理念和方向，如果被某旁支细节忽悠了，你就大错，今天选共和党人就是要：

重建法制RULE & ORDER

重建正常的社会秩序

让躺在沙发上空享福利的人重新工作

让有能力的人获得最多的机会而不是根据肤色种族

，，，，，

另外NBC的matt居然问trump太太是否自己写这演讲，演讲有专业加工是常识，他问过OB的演讲是自己写的吗？？

[TJKCB]

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 时事述评 ? Ms. Trump lied.

全部论坛列表





Ms. Trump lied.

　



来源: Derrick_Liu 于 2016-07-19 09:50:42 [档案] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：29 次 (584 bytes)

字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题


本文内容已被 [ Derrick_Liu ] 在 2016-07-19 09:57:24 编辑过。如有问题，请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

回答: 先用你们的标准看看你家Michelle Obama有没有这两段话的版权 由 smalleagle 于 2016-07-19 09:48:27



That is the most damaging part. She did not have the kind of DEGREE she claimed to have. And she did not write the kind of speech she claimed to have written.

Ms. Trump should not have pretended she were as intelligent as the current first lady. Ms. Obama does have a real Harvard degree to back up her claims. Ms. Trump has nothing in the category.

Therefore, Ms. Trump is a Pretender, not a contender! It proves once again that it is not what it SOUNDS like to win people's trust. It is your TRUE words that win people over!

[TJKCB]

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 子女教育 ? Maybe. Here is a test:

全部论坛列表





Maybe. Here is a test:

　



来源: Derrick_Liu 于 2016-07-19 10:50:26 [档案] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：23 次 (318 bytes)

字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题


本文内容已被 [ Derrick_Liu ] 在 2016-07-19 10:54:31 编辑过。如有问题，请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

回答: 也许她就是加了那句 keep your promise... 由 backyardfun 于 2016-07-19 10:47:55



Give Ms. Trump a pen and a dozen lined paper. Ask her to recall what she said during her speech last night.

If she could recalled more than half of her speech, she will get an A . . .

But my guess is that she will get an F, because she would have mispelled many, many words . . .

[TJKCB]

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 子女教育 ? 昨天川普太太那一场演砸了吧。

全部论坛列表





昨天川普太太那一场演砸了吧。

　



来源: 千里一盏灯 于 2016-07-19 10:16:40 [档案] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：280 次 (170 bytes)

字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题




感觉大家都很努力，但还是文化水平不高。同样的段子，比米笑当年的差远了。

受过藤校教育还是不一样啊。



已有2位网友点赞!查看








好书推荐：“All the Light We Cannot See” by Anthony Doerr

推荐一本历史小书，主要是欧洲史

2015年看的几本书

我在北京雾霾时用这个面具！

强力推荐的一本好书，家长不妨买一本来读读(图)

家有5年级的男娃全家必看的一本书



亚马逊所有书都30% off,趁机给孩子买了好多书！

减少疲劳：给网虫们推荐一样非常适用的东西

一个小小的的detector或许会挽救很多人的生命

正在看一本帮助男孩成长的书，一点笔记

推荐两本新书，应该对孩子的思维很有帮助

给大家推荐一本书 希望培养孩子研究科学的家长看

推荐Wordly Wise 3000的书

犹太推儿经：看到B-，犹爸会不会怒发冲kipa？

强烈推荐给大人孩子都要读：高效能孩子的七个习惯

推荐一本家有 Teenager 的好书

想知道如何进理想大学？推荐二本书，很有帮助

有关孩子阅读，介绍一套相当不错的书

推荐一本书 Gifted Lives by Joan Freeman





千里一盏灯发过的热帖：
?我去，Pokestop竟然有希拉蕊的人埋伏着。
?暑假已经过时了。
?请教一下，这个pokemon go是个什么东西？听说还能挣钱？
?这小姑娘想要个ipad.
?最省心的孩子不是自推的，而是那种一推就动，而且怎么推就怎么动的。
?据说真正的racism是这样的（回答一下高精粉）
?父母背景对学校申请有影响吗？
?美国怎么不搞个国庆长假呀，休息一个星期多好。
?犯不着拼着命的去给天才们当垫底，人家我咱们不是一个物种。
?周末转俩笑话

您的位置： 文学城 ? 论坛 ? 子女教育 ? 昨天川普太太那一场演砸了吧。


所有跟帖：



? 没看。怎么砸了啊？藤校出身的老婆自然能说会道些。debate team不是白去滴。 -篱笆08- ♀ 给 篱笆08 发送悄悄话 篱笆08 的博客首页 篱笆08 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (7 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:27:00

? 你大囡应该往这方面发展，做什么码工啊。 -孔方兄5- ♂ 给 孔方兄5 发送悄悄话 孔方兄5 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:34:14

? 啥意思呀，是争取做第一夫人？ -缘去缘来- ♂ 给 缘去缘来 发送悄悄话 缘去缘来 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:36:13

? LOL。想都没想过。 -篱笆08- ♀ 给 篱笆08 发送悄悄话 篱笆08 的博客首页 篱笆08 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:39:49

? 现在想还来得及，志向高点，争取你培养出两个第一夫人 -缘去缘来- ♂ 给 缘去缘来 发送悄悄话 缘去缘来 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:42:52

? 咋可能啊？这也太为难我了。 -篱笆08- ♀ 给 篱笆08 发送悄悄话 篱笆08 的博客首页 篱笆08 的个人群组 (169 bytes) (4 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:46:23

? 说不好听的，就是东施效颦。当然讲的是谈吐，不是颜值。而且后来欲盖弥彰！说是自己写的，越描越黑。 -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (368 bytes) (58 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:34:23

? 这如果不是抄袭的话，那就没有东西是抄袭了。 -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:39:05

? LOL, 是不是说明民主党和共和党价值观一样啊？ -backyardfun- ♀ 给 backyardfun 发送悄悄话 backyardfun 的个人群组 (71 bytes) (13 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:41:13

? It is laughable because . . . -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (569 bytes) (36 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:42:12

? 也许她就是加了那句 keep your promise... -backyardfun- ♀ 给 backyardfun 发送悄悄话 backyardfun 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (4 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:47:55

? Maybe. Here is a test: -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (318 bytes) (22 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:50:26

? 鼓动人心的语录其实也就那些, -bayareama- ♀ 给 bayareama 发送悄悄话 bayareama 的个人群组 (135 bytes) (16 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:41:54

? Ms. Trump claimed that she WROTE her speech . . . -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (65 bytes) (13 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:43:05

? Media is always harsh on -bayareama- ♀ 给 bayareama 发送悄悄话 bayareama 的个人群组 (164 bytes) (9 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:54:23

? Ms. Obama did not claim to walk on runway! -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:55:16

? 英文不是母语毕竟会有一些劣势。她的口音让我想起Schwarzenegger当年做加州州长发言的口音. -bayareama- ♀ 给 bayareama 发送悄悄话 bayareama 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:37:51

? Not fair to compare her to Mrs. Obama on public speach skills. --worldance-- ♀ 给 -worldance- 发送悄悄话 -worldance- 的个人群组 (258 bytes) (23 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:38:57

? You miss the point. Honesty is the issue here. -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (236 bytes) (20 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:39:44

? well, i was responding to OP, this wasn't the issue --worldance-- ♀ 给 -worldance- 发送悄悄话 -worldance- 的个人群组 (129 bytes) (11 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:46:24

? Read between the lines . . . 同样的段子， -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (178 bytes) (20 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:47:19

? 总的来说昨天共和党的名角太少，过几天民主党开会肯定是满台大腕，一下就把他们比下去了。 -千里一盏灯- ♂ 给 千里一盏灯 发送悄悄话 千里一盏灯 的博客首页 千里一盏灯 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:44:43

? 不一样的感觉吧。M.O.给人女强人的感觉，M.T.她还是温婉很多 -WISEBAO- ♀ 给 WISEBAO 发送悄悄话 WISEBAO 的博客首页 WISEBAO 的个人群组 (53 bytes) (19 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:46:03

? 是。谁真在乎她说什么。好看就行 -greenoasis- ♀ 给 greenoasis 发送悄悄话 greenoasis 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 10:52:03

? 难道"温婉"是用来形容她的？trump的第一个太太还够档次，这个简直就是一bimbo -AlexisMom- ♀ 给 AlexisMom 发送悄悄话 AlexisMom 的博客首页 AlexisMom 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 11:00:08

? Harsh! -Derrick_Liu- ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 postreply 11:02:49

[TJKCB]

先用你们的标准看看你家Michelle Obama有没有这两段话的版权

　



来源: smalleagle 于 2016-07-19 09:48:27 [档案] [博客] [旧帖] [给我悄悄话] 本文已被阅读：16 次 (2876 bytes)

字体：调大/重置/调小 | 加入书签 | 打印 | 所有跟帖 | 加跟贴 | 当前最热讨论主题


本文内容已被 [ smalleagle ] 在 2016-07-19 09:57:42 编辑过。如有问题，请报告版主或论坛管理删除.

回答: RNC plagiarism ? 由 TJKCB 于 2016-07-19 09:25:18



这是左棍们认为抄袭黑女人的一句话：



Melania Trump -- July, 2016: "We need to pass those lessons on to the many generations to follow," she said. "Because we want our children in this nation to know that the only limit to your achievements is the strength of your dreams and your willingness to work for them."

Michelle Obama -- August, 2008: "Barack and I set out to build lives guided by these values and to pass them onto the next generation, because we want our children — and all children in this nation — to know that the only limit to the height of your achievements is the reach of your dreams and your willingness to work hard for them."





但是只要多做一下research，还有不少人比黑女人更早说过类似的话比如：



Will Steger's 1989 book, Crossing Antarctica：

"As I learned anew in crossing Antarctica, the only limit to achievement is the limit you place on your own dreams."

还有 Michelle中使用Working hard, treating people with dignity and respect, and keeping your promises -- or knowing that "your word is your bond" 的段子：



Michelle Obama -- August, 2008: "And Barack and I were raised with so many of the same values: like, you work hard for what you want in life, that your word is your bond, that you do what you say you're going to do, that you treat people with dignity and respect, even if you don't know them and even if you don't agree with them."

类似的例子：

The values of honesty, hard work, and treating others as you'd like to be treated ring a lot more like the age-old "Golden Rule" combined with a little bit of the "Cowboy Code of Ethics" -- 早于2008；

2001 obituary 出版的书中：

"He [my father] taught me .... how to work hard, how to be respectful of others, how to play a guitar, how your word is your bond..."

所以左棍先别提侵权，先看看你家黑女人有版权吗？

[TJKCB]

? RNC plagiarism ? - TJKCB - ♀ 给 TJKCB 发送悄悄话 TJKCB 的博客首页 TJKCB 的个人群组 (33082 bytes) (125 reads) 07/19/2016 09:25:18

? It is laughable because . . . - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (822 bytes) (27 reads) 07/19/2016 09:45:11 (1)

? If Trumps copy DNC, why do we need Trumps? That's the point... - TJKCB - ♀ 给 TJKCB 发送悄悄话 TJKCB 的博客首页 TJKCB 的个人群组 (261 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 10:12:45

? well-checked, side-by-side, welcome fact-based, not name-calling - TJKCB - ♀ 给 TJKCB 发送悄悄话 TJKCB 的博客首页 TJKCB 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 10:15:16

? 先用你们的标准看看你家Michelle Obama有没有这两段话的版权 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (2876 bytes) (12 reads) 07/19/2016 09:48:27

? Ms. Trump lied. - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (584 bytes) (18 reads) 07/19/2016 09:50:42

? 希拉里lie是有FBI的调查为证的，你的证据呢？你觉得只凭你没有证据的叫两声就可以了？ - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (3 reads) 07/19/2016 09:55:35

? So you conceded that - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (96 bytes) (9 reads) 07/19/2016 09:58:14 (1)

[TJKCB]

? 抄袭?---媒体许多舆论只能当热闹看 - 楷若 - ♀ 给 楷若 发送悄悄话 楷若 的个人群组 (3538 bytes) (50 reads) 07/19/2016 09:44:06

? 谈抄袭是左棍自己把脸凑上来给人打---就用左棍的标准看看Michelle Obama有没有这两段话的版权 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (2876 bytes) (13 reads) 07/19/2016 09:47:22


? 好消息，川阵大将说大家都乃劣等人种 - 笨狼 - ♂ 给 笨狼 发送悄悄话 笨狼 的博客首页 笨狼 的个人群组 (2376 bytes) (109 reads) 07/19/2016 09:36:33

? 散了吧，人家说的是西方文明对于世界的贡献远远高于其他种族-----大家都乃劣等人种是惟恐天下不乱的左棍自己加工的 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 09:45:21


? RNC plagiarism ? - TJKCB - ♀ 给 TJKCB 发送悄悄话 TJKCB 的博客首页 TJKCB 的个人群组 (32849 bytes) (95 reads) 07/19/2016 09:25:18

? It is laughable because . . . - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (822 bytes) (18 reads) 07/19/2016 09:45:11 (1)

? 先用你们的标准看看你家Michelle Obama有没有这两段话的版权 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (2876 bytes) (8 reads) 07/19/2016 09:48:27

? Ms. Trump lied. - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (584 bytes) (16 reads) 07/19/2016 09:50:42

? 希拉里lie是有FBI的调查为证的，你的证据呢？你觉得只凭你没有证据的叫两声就可以了？ - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (2 reads) 07/19/2016 09:55:35

? So you conceded that - Derrick_Liu - ♂ 给 Derrick_Liu 发送悄悄话 Derrick_Liu 的个人群组 (96 bytes) (5 reads) 07/19/2016 09:58:14


? 别提侵权，先看看Michelle Obama 有版权吗？-看看同样标准下Michelle Obama是不是也是Plagiariz - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (7614 bytes) (156 reads) 07/19/2016 09:10:17 (2)

? 说的好，Michelle也是拿来主义者。 - ThisMyWords - ♂ 给 ThisMyWords 发送悄悄话 ThisMyWords 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (1 reads) 07/19/2016 09:16:55

? 按左棍逻辑逐句分析一下Michelle的演讲她后面要跟1米多长的ref list--不仅挑战智商底线还挑战常识底线 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (107 bytes) (4 reads) 07/19/2016 09:20:30

? 左棍不好意思又打了你们的脸了。实在你们太热情把脸伸过来的啊。 - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 09:17:02

? 是不是只要比左棍们早说出尼玛这两个字以后可以就可以坐家里收左棍们的专利授权费了？ - smalleagle - ♂ 给 smalleagle 发送悄悄话 smalleagle 的博客首页 smalleagle 的个人群组 (0 bytes) (0 reads) 07/19/2016 09:22:12

? 有软件可以用，内容相同，句子结构也要相同。教授抓学生很容易的。其实，她把句子结构改一下就可以躲避。因为 - 笑薇. - ♀ 给 笑薇. 发送悄悄话 笑薇. 的博客首页 笑薇. 的个人群组 (201 bytes) (33 reads) 07/19/2016 09:27:39