译窗

国际时事新闻翻译
正文

that's crap. let me give you some criticism

(2007-03-19 09:00:55) 下一个
you are just playing with words, for the sole purpose of confusing yourself. 社会才有阶段性,不是社会形态有阶段!? Clever wording, though only for me to poop on. Think about it. When I say my life has various stages, I really mean some aspects of my life have stages. My life as a collective concept, encompassing different things, cannot be really divided into stages in a strict sense. Likewise, you claim that society has different stages, but the form of society doesn't is nonsense.

But that's not the key problem you have. Your main theme is the undesignability of a society, or its form. But that's just your claim. You are saying it as a conviction before you can prove it. To constitute a proof for what you are claiming, you will need phenomenology and a plausible underlying mechanism. By phenomenology I mean observations of signs that are apparently consistent or inconsistent with your theory, from past history to current state of matters. By a mechanism I mean a coherent chain that deomonstrates the causality of the facts, and the, at least partial, inevitablity of your theory.

As far as I am concerned, you have not deomonstrated your ability to come up with a coherent theory. Most of your posts are just playing with the high words most people don't care to understand. These high words may serve well to confuse you, too.
[ 打印 ]
阅读 ()评论 (0)
评论
目前还没有任何评论
登录后才可评论.