涅高兹大师(Heinrich Neuhaus)弹奏肖邦第一钢协第二乐章(Romance)

这个演奏远高于现代的演奏. 演奏家最终还是有自己的声音,体现的是自己的质地.
不愧为俄罗斯学派的一代宗师,教出了Gilels,Richter,Zak,Lupu等大家.
这里表现情感是古典里的高贵(nobleness),而不是流行的那种恨不得开肠剖腹似的倾诉.
后者其实是把握不了自己的表现力而哗众取宠,似乎是和肥皂剧争市场.
亚洲男演奏家继续那样, 会成为笑柄.

[julia42163]

非常感谢, 你的posting. 赞同你的观点

[种菜得菜]

回复weston的评论:
此曲油管里面能找到的所有我已都听过，还听过傅聪的。很期待听到尚未听过的。

[weston]

回复种菜得菜的评论:
哪天有空我把几个前辈大师的上了到时候再华山论剑.

[种菜得菜]

One of the most beautiful Chopin piano pieces, it's so moving that is completely beyond my ability to describe. I was listening to same piece by Emil Gilels almost every day in the past few weeks and thought it was the best version I've ever listened. Well,the Neuhaus's recording you posted here is equally impressive and admirable.

Have to say that Lang Lang's play of this piece is not that bad at all comparing to the rest performers out there (the young generation). Here is the link of Lang Lang's play I watched http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aM3t8_iES24 (containing Romance)

[britannica]

肥皂剧争市场:))

是啊，音乐本身的表现力才重要。